Artificial intelligence continues to permeate various industries, and the music world is experiencing arguably the most revolutionary shift. AI-generated music is becoming more sophisticated and ubiquitous, prompting a slew of legal questions about ownership, creativity, and copyright. The industry has made progress in controlling it, but much more needs to be done. Here, we explore the most famous legal battles over AI-generated music, outlining the evolving landscape of copyright in the music industry and what the future holds.
The “Daddy’s Car” Case: Creativity and Copyright
In 2016, Sony CSL Research Laboratory introduced “Daddy’s Car,” a song composed by AI using a database of The Beatles’ music. The song garnered significant attention, raising questions about creativity and ownership. The central issue was whether the creators of the AI, the users who input the data, or the AI itself could claim ownership of the song – as well as the extent to which the song constituted copyright infringement. Although no legal action was taken, the case sparked a global debate about how copyright laws apply to AI-generated works and who, if anyone, should be credited as the creator.
The Jay-Z AI Deepfake: Right to Voice and Likeness
In 2020, AI-generated versions of Jay-Z’s voice were used to create new renditions of popular songs. The deepfake versions were so convincing that they raised concerns about the use of an artist’s voice without permission. Jay-Z’s legal team issued takedown notices, arguing that the unauthorized use of his voice violated his rights.
This case highlighted the broader issue of using AI to replicate an artist’s voice or likeness without consent, posing significant challenges for copyright and personality rights laws and arguably highlighting a new pain point which was later addressed by legislation such as the 2024 Elvis Act – a bill which offered copyright protection to an artist's voice & likeness.
The "Heart on My Sleeve" Controversy: AI and Human Voices
In early 2023, an anonymous artist using the moniker Ghostwriter created a viral sensation with the song "Heart on My Sleeve," which featured AI-generated renditions of the voices of popular artists Drake and The Weeknd. Many fans were convinced that the song was leaked by the artists; a scary reality for artistic integrity and its relation to copyright. The song was quickly removed from major streaming platforms like Spotify and Apple Music due to copyright infringement claims.
This case yet again underscored the contentious issue of using AI to replicate famous voices without consent, raising significant questions about intellectual property and the rights of artists over their own voices.
Suno and Udio vs. RIAA: The Latest Legal Battle Over AI-Generated Music
In June 2024, the RIAA filed lawsuits against AI music platforms Suno and Udio, accusing them of copyright infringement. The RIAA claimed these platforms used AI to generate music that mimicked the styles and voices of popular artists without proper licensing, thereby violating intellectual property rights. Suno and Udio defended their AI-generated music as transformative and original, arguing it should be considered fair use.
This case has significant implications for the future of AI in music. If the RIAA succeeds, it could lead to stricter regulations and licensing requirements, potentially stifling innovation. However, a victory for Suno and Udio could set a precedent for broader acceptance of AI-generated music, challenging traditional notions of originality and copyright.
Conclusion
These case studies demonstrate that, as AI continues to advance, the music industry must grapple with complex legal and ethical questions surrounding ownership and authorship. The lack of clear guidelines on AI-generated music underscores the need for updated copyright laws that can accommodate the nuances of this emerging technology. As AI becomes an increasingly prominent tool in music creation, the legal battles of today will shape the future of music copyright for generations to come.
Looking to safeguarding your musical copyright from generative AI clones? Learn more about CoverNet, our AI-powered copyright scanning service, here: https://www.covernet.ai/